This Sticky Toffee Orkney Broonie is a delicious twist on a traditional Scottish bake.
Originally featured in F. Marian McNeill’s classic 1929 cookbook The Scots Kitchen, this oat-based gingerbread loaf has been reinvented by the Hebridean Baker as a rich traybake, generously topped with sticky toffee sauce. A true taste of autumn, perfect for sharing with family and friends.
Method
In a bowl, whisk together the eggs, buttermilk and milk.
In a pan over a medium heat, melt together the butter, sugar and black treacle until combined and stir in the porridge oats.
In another bowl, add all the other dry ingredients and mix in the eggy milk mixture, then the oaty treacle mixture and combine.
Meanwhile, make the sauce. Add the butter, sugar and black treacle to a pan and simmer until the sugar has dissolved and the butter melted. Then turn up the heat and let it bubble for a minute or so to create a dark toffee-coloured sauce. Take it off the heat and stir in the cream.
As soon as the broonie is out of the oven, prick the cooked sponge pudding all over with a cocktail stick and pour about a quarter of the warm sauce over.
Hamlyns is the official porridge of Coinneach MacLeod, the Hebridean Baker.
Coinneach was born and raised on the Isle of Lewis the most northerly of the Outer Hebrides of Scotland.
Inspired by traditional family recipes and the folklore of the islands, the Hebridean Baker cookbooks have made him one of Scotland’s bestselling authors. His regular television appearances, North American book tours and social media content have motivated his worldwide followers to bake, forage, learn Gaelic, enjoy a dram or two of whisky and to seek a more wholesome, simple life.
Sharing his adventures along with his partner Peter, Coinneach aims to bring the best of the Scottish islands to a worldwide audience.
Coinneach’s first cookbook, Recipes and Wee Stories from the Scottish Islands, was published in 2021. From croft loaf to cranachan chocolate bombs, and oaty apricot cookies to Harris Gin cocktails, there’s something for everyone.
A second book, My Scottish Island Kitchen, followed in 2022. It’s packed with wonderful stories and fabulous photography and includes lovely recipes divided into chapters including Scottish recipes, cakes and biscuits, cosy weekend dishes, bread & scones, afternoon tea recipes and much more.
For The Hebridean Baker at Home Coinneach travelled from Islay, via Barra, Uist, Berneray and Harris before arriving home to Lewis. He shares recipes and stories that have been handed down through the generations, bakes that celebrate the flavours of Scotland and simple dishes that you can whip up from store cupboard ingredients.
His latest book, The Hebridean Baker: The Scottish Cookbook, is a celebration of Scotland’s timeless culinary traditions including heart-warming soups and pies, show-stopping desserts and mouth-watering cakes, along with irresistible biscuits which are sure to become future family favourites.
You’ll find some of these recipes in the Hebridean Baker section of our recipe library, and on the Hebridean Baker website.



